Albums to watch

Thrashing Thru The Passion

The Hold Steady

Thrashing Thru The Passion

Album number seven, and first in five years, from the Brooklyn-based indie rock five-piece led by raconteur Craig Finn

ADM rating[?]

7.1

Label
Frenchkiss
UK Release date
09/08/2019
US Release date
09/08/2019
  1. 9.0 |   God Is In The TV

    Sometimes an album is so good it makes you want to cry. This is one such occasion
    Read Review

  2. 8.9 |   Paste Magazine

    Thrashing Thru The Passion is musically looser than previous offerings—fewer ballads, the big rock numbers less lush and more compact—but it also makes it accessible to new listeners, who can then work their way back through albums like Heaven is Whenever or Separation Sunday
    Read Review

  3. 8.3 |   A.V. Club

    “Denver Haircut” features another potentially meta observation: “It doesn’t have to be pure. It doesn’t have to be perfect. Just sort of has to be worth it.” No Finn-ish qualifiers needed here. It’s worth it
    Read Review

  4. 8.0 |   All Music

    Feels mature but not stuffy or settled; it's the sound of a group that cherishes their own peculiar chemistry and choose to bask within the righteous noise they make
    Read Review

  5. 8.0 |   The Arts Desk

    The band’s tightest and most fun album since 2008
    Read Review

  6. 8.0 |   The Guardian

    Craig Finn’s barstool-rock raconteurs paint a portrait of booze-soaked Americana with their most enthralling record in years
    Read Review

  7. 8.0 |   PopMatters

    The classic rock-inspired Hold Steady sound revitalized on their latest, Thrashing Thru the Passion, with keyboardist Franz Nicolay back and a horn section in tow
    Read Review

  8. 8.0 |   Uncut

    It might not be the best Hold Steady Album, but it might be their most purely enjoyable. Print edition only

  9. 8.0 |   Exclaim

    Is this record a return to their early greatness? Let's maybe leave that for the legion of dedicated disciples to argue about, but at the very least it's bound to hit all the familiar pleasure centres of Hold Steady fans
    Read Review

  10. 8.0 |   NME

    The band's spent over a decade-and-a-half sharing their stories about those in and out of love, the broken and the bruised. It's business as usual, and business is good
    Read Review

  11. 8.0 |   Pitchfork

    The Brooklyn indie rock institution’s seventh album is as joyous and rousing as their best efforts
    Read Review

  12. 8.0 |   The Quietus

    The stories, the addled street preacher, the joie de vivre, they’re more potent than for a long time. The playing is better too. And yes, Finn is a singer now but he’s still instinctive enough to pile into his good old declamatory mosh. For stretches, this truly feels like bopping to the classics
    Read Review

  13. 8.0 |   American Songwriter

    The total effect of Thrashing Thru The Passion is that of The Hold Steady at their most casual and confident, tossing off these songs that would be tour de forces for anyone else as if they have a bushelful of them just hanging around the studio
    Read Review

  14. 7.5 |   Spectrum Culture

    Thrashing is the work of a band artfully redefining what they want to be after 15 years together
    Read Review

  15. 7.0 |   music OMH

    It may not be there with their best work, and it might be seen by some as a bit of a stopgap, but there are still times on Thrashing Thru The Passion that The Hold Steady can effortlessly remind us that they remain the ‘best bar band in the world’
    Read Review

  16. 7.0 |   Rolling Stone

    The band’s their first album in five years is a return to form after a couple overly serious LPs
    Read Review

  17. 7.0 |   Slant Magazine

    While the album may lack instant anthems, it’s still a highly consistent and satisfying rock album
    Read Review

  18. 6.5 |   Under The Radar

    It's a good, solid rock record — but whether that's a good thing or not may depend on whether you think a band that were once touted as the next Replacements are built to stake their claim as a heritage act or should have called time a decade ago. We're firmly in the former camp
    Read Review

  19. 6.0 |   The Skinny

    The Hold Steady's seventh album collects five new songs recorded this year alongside five digitally-released singles the band put out sporadically between 2017 and 2019
    Read Review

  20. 6.0 |   Mojo

    A stopgap isn't quite what The Hold Steady need right now, but as a holding exercise it's hard to fault. Print edition only

  21. 6.0 |   DIY

    Seven albums in, The Hold Steady are very much a band for their existing fans
    Read Review

  22. 6.0 |   Punk News

    As much as I wanted to love this album, it simply falls flat for me
    Read Review

  23. 5.0 |   No Ripcord

    Some good ol', serviceable rock ' roll always goes down easy, but with The Hold Steady, we know they're capable of so much more
    Read Review

  24. 4.0 |   Q

    Falls well short of greatness, reheating past ideas to the point of cliche. Print edition only

  25. 4.0 |   Loud And Quiet

    It’s largely disappointing, although lyrically solid, as Craig Finn’s charismatic vocals pair perfectly with his rambling, narrated lyrics. But you were probably expecting that
    Read Review


blog comments powered by Disqus

Watch it

Roll over video for more options

Hear it

Latest Reviews

More reviews