-
8.5
143206
8.5 |
Under The Radar
NEW
The story is compelling, the songs exquisite, the lyrics diamond sharp, and the melodies so catchy they get lodged in your head long after the album has finished. Let’s hope Darnielle’s next dream yields something as wonderful as this
Read Review
-
8.0
143207
8.0 |
The Guardian
NEW
The latest themed album from John Darnielle’s band – with some help from Lin-Manuel Miranda – takes them on a sumptuously crafted and surprisingly upbeat voyage to a desert island
Read Review
-
8.0
143209
8.0 |
All Music
NEW
Through This Fire Across from Peter Balkan plays more like a concept album than the Original Cast album from some unproduced musical waiting for its moment on Broadway, but this music confirms the Mountain Goats have talent that's on par with their ambitions, and this album is a thoughtful, dramatically satisfying experience
Read Review
-
8.0
143211
8.0 |
Uncut
NEW
As disaster mounts for these ill-prepared moderns, the soft '70s New Orleans brass of "Through This Night" is among the musical balms. Print edition only
-
7.7
143227
7.7 |
Spectrum Culture
NEW
Through This Fire Across from Peter Balkan pushes The Mountain Goats into new territory as a band and as storytellers, marking a rich new entry worthy of close reading, musically and lyrically
Read Review
-
7.4
143208
7.4 |
Paste Magazine
NEW
John Darnielle trades the lo-fi confessional for high tragedy, finding transcendence—albeit a touch of distance—in the performance of survival.
Read Review
-
7.0
143210
7.0 |
PopMatters
NEW
Derived from a dream, the Mountain Goats’ new musical tells the intimate and vivid tale of the lone survivors from a shipwrecked crew
Read Review
-
7.0
143212
7.0 |
Pitchfork
NEW
The musical tale of three shipwrecked souls makes for an unusually linear Mountain Goats record, full of powerful moments that not even the eternally moving John Darnielle can scrape into the whole it deserves
Read Review
-