Albums to watch

banner
Heaven Is Whenever

The Hold Steady

Heaven Is Whenever

The supposedly 'less anthemic' 5th album from the Brooklyn alt.rockers

ADM rating[?]

6.8

Label
Vagrant
UK Release date
04/05/2010
  1. 8.0 |   Uncut

    It's the natural, assured way in which Heaven Is Whenever moves between building on past glories and breaking fresh ground that's so impressive
    Read Review

  2. 8.0 |   NME

    Print edition only

  3. 8.0 |   The Independent

    The departure of keyboardist Franz Nicolay has left welcome spaces in The Hold Steady's sound
    Read Review

  4. 8.0 |   The Guardian

    This transitional album indicates there is more in their locker
    Read Review

  5. 8.0 |   music OMH

    Another gem for an amazingly consistent band with plenty of room left to grow
    Read Review

  6. 8.0 |   The Observer

    This collection is subtly excellent... Singer Craig Finn's lyrics remain a joy
    Read Review

  7. 8.0 |   Rolling Stone

    Heaven is more musically compact than the band's last album, 2008's Stay Positiv
    Read Review

  8. 8.0 |   The Quietus

    Maybe they are just getting older, which is fine, as this is a band who has always grasped positive vibes from the move toward greyness. Indeed, that is the very point of this beautifully unglamorous gang of a band
    Read Review

  9. 8.0 |   Daily Telegraph

    This fifth record is more spirited, translating the departure of their keyboard player into a leaner, hard-riffing sound
    Read Review

  10. 8.0 |   Rave Magazine

    Living vicariously through the lives of others is rarely this entertaining or satisfying
    Read Review

  11. 7.2 |   Beats Per Minute

    Great bands always struggle to match their past musical output. Take it for what it is – a guitar-centric party rock record – and it won’t disappoint
    Read Review

  12. 7.0 |   The Sunday Times

    The Hold Steady are a one-trick pony. But what a trick
    Read Review

  13. 7.0 |   No Ripcord

    There are some missteps on this album, but the last line on the record, which comes at the end of the seven-minute closer, is a perfect sign-off: “This shouldn’t hurt, but you might feel a slight discomfort”
    Read Review

  14. 7.0 |   The Line Of Best Fit

    This is no longer an experiment in repurposing some of the most outre moments of pop rock; it’s an institution and each album’s success rests on its songs. Rejoice: Heaven is Whenever delivers
    Read Review

  15. 7.0 |   Blurt

    Given the band's skill and experience, it's not surprising that most of the album's strongest tracks are riff-rockers. As for the experiments, sometimes they work, sometimes they don't
    Read Review

  16. 6.5 |   Bowlegs

    Still depicts street level America, and the band still sound like a stadium filling bar-room rock band, whilst the energy and unapologetic attitude is as blatant as ever
    Read Review

  17. 6.2 |   Pitchfork

    Despite the confidence of that opening track, Heaven Is Whenever sounds like a transitional album, hopefully paving the way for something stronger, more cohesive, more specific.
    Read Review

  18. 6.0 |   Pop Matters

    This album gives us a new energy, one that comes on subtly, that earns its way through, and will last a lot longer than Holly’s high used to
    Read Review

  19. 6.0 |   Scotland on Sunday

    Finn's voice sounds more flexible than before. Springsteen should seriously consider covering the closing A Slight Discomfort
    Read Review

  20. 6.0 |   Evening Standard

    At their best — The Weekenders, The Smidge — the Hold Steady have a dynamism, the lack of which leaves much US rock churning in the mire
    Read Review

  21. 6.0 |   The Times

    The ghostly chorus of Barely Breathing and shimmering riffs of The Weekender are the highlights of an album that tends to slip back into a trademark groove of chugging power-chords
    Read Review

  22. 6.0 |   The Digital Fix

    Heaven Is Whenever is not a bad album, far from it, there is just an inescapable feeling is that something, or someone is missing
    Read Review

  23. 6.0 |   The Irish Times

    It portrays them as a band at a crossroads: lighters aloft at one fork, at the other a formlessness where frenzied light rock calls the shots
    Read Review

  24. 6.0 |   Mojo

    A rewarding listen with a definite touch of Groundhog Day about it. Print edition only

  25. 6.0 |   Q

    This is Everyman music with a peacock strut; yet the production gloss is a mixed blessing. Print edition only

  26. 6.0 |   The Skinny

    Lacks a certain je ne sais quoi due to the departure of keyboardist Franz Nicolay, known for his killer ‘tache and deftly blending harpsichord and synth into the meat-and-potato rock
    Read Review

  27. 6.0 |   Drowned In Sound

    While The Hold Steady haven't made a bad album this time, they haven't made a really good one either. It's a good album with some problems
    Read Review

  28. 6.0 |   Under The Radar

    Despite the veteran group putting in a valiant effort, Heaven Is Whenever will largely be known as "the transitional LP"
    Read Review

  29. 6.0 |   Spin

    The Midwest's ambassadors to Brooklyn hone their ballsy bar-band philosophizing with a focus worthy of CSI
    Read Review

  30. 6.0 |   Independent on Sunday

    They're pretty good and they're heartfelt. But for all their raging guitars, they're exciting only some of the time
    Read Review

  31. 6.0 |   FasterLouder

    The poetry is still there but the fire and brimstone of the music just does not seem to bring anything flash to the party
    Read Review

blog comments powered by Disqus

Watch it

Roll over video for more options

Hear it

Preview & download it

The Hold Steady: Heaven Is Whenever

  • Download full album for just £7.99
  • 1. The Sweet Part of the City £0.99
  • 2. Soft in the Center £0.99
  • 3. The Weekenders £0.99
  • 4. The Smidge £0.99
  • 5. Rock Problems £0.99
  • 6. We Can Get Together £0.99
  • 7. Hurricane J £0.99
  • 8. Barely Breathing £0.99
  • 9. Our Whole Lives £0.99
  • 10. A Slight Discomfort £0.99
  • Service provided by 7Digital

Latest Reviews

More reviews