- 
			8.0
			35786
			
				8.0 |  
				Q
			
				The latest skinny-jeaned claimants to the indie-rock thrown long vacated by The Strokes. Print edition only
				
 
 
- 
			8.0
			35961
			
				8.0 |  
				NME
			
				An effortlessly brilliant debut
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			8.0
			35987
			
				8.0 |  
				musicOMH
			
				Howler, when at their best, produce simple, but infectious, dirty rock music that oozes confidence and a nonchalant swagger
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			8.0
			36042
			
				8.0 |  
				The Guardian
			
				The success of America Give Up depends entirely on the quality of the songs, and Howler have enough good ones to remind you of how good the Strokes used to be
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			8.0
			36076
			
				8.0 |  
				The Fly
			
				America’s next great guitar group? This is it
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			7.5
			36162
			
				7.5 |  
				A.V. Club
			
				America Give Up is about woo-oo-oo choruses and fuzz-laden, spiky guitar chords, and there’s nothing wrong with that
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			7.5
			35953
			
				7.5 |  
				BBC
			
				An album of thoroughly contagious, albeit fairly derivative, Strokes-flavoured gutter-rock
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			7.0
			36359
			
				7.0 |  
				Rave Magazine
			
				America Give Up is a smart, unapologetic album that will take its place admirably on the crest of the surfy, garage pop-wave thing or whatever…
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			7.0
			36559
			
				7.0 |  
				PopMatters
			
				Alongside the likes of the Horrors, Yuck and the Smith Westerns, there rumbles a burgeoning resistance to the dying of the rock ‘n’ roll light. In other words, comrades, we may still have a pulse
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36734
			
				6.0 |  
				State 
			
				A pleasant piece of slacker-pop and rock n’ roll pastiche
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			37371
			
				6.0 |  
				The AU Review
			
				On the whole, no new ground is being covered here, but it all seems to have the authenticity that’s required to pass muster
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36506
			
				6.0 |  
				Pitchfork
			
				A pretty typical rock group's first album. And there's absolutely nothing wrong with that
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36245
			
				6.0 |  
				No Ripcord
			
				Even if this sound has been done more successfully, the reverse is also true
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36346
			
				6.0 |  
				The Digital Fix
			
				There are no real highlights: it just demands to be played in a one-er, loudly. And maybe even spun once again
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36084
			
				6.0 |  
				The Observer
			
				Howler are probably not the second coming. But they are just the sort of boys guitar pop's true believers gravitate towards. And they are so much better than those false prophets of yesteryear, the Drums
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36150
			
				6.0 |  
				The Scotsman
			
				Howler’s chances of propelling themselves beyond the middle of the league table will stand and fall on how ferociously they can put this album across live
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36067
			
				6.0 |  
				Evening Standard
			
				The angst can be wearying and they do slip into lazy Cramps territory on Pythagorean Fearem but their ball is rolling?...
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			36033
			
				6.0 |  
				The Irish Times
			
				What makes Howler such a cute proposition is their dedication to the art of skilful pilfering
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			6.0
			35927
			
				6.0 |  
				The Line Of Best Fit
			
				Half good is not good enough
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			4.0
			35785
			
				4.0 |  
				The Skinny
			
				The debts to The Jesus and Mary Chain's Psychocandy and The Strokes' Is This It are so pervasive on this debut album that they obscure any sense of a band establishing their own sound
				
 Read Review
 
- 
			4.0
			35793
			
				4.0 |  
				Uncut
			
				Often too light and derivative to suggest they really are saviours in waiting. Print edition only
				
 
 
- 
			4.0
			35897
			
				4.0 |  
				Bowlegs
			
				A record that has borrowed far too much to find its own personality
				
 Read Review
 
-